Graphic courtesy of Kelly Quintana.

SNL has been going through…let’s say, a transition phase lately. Over the last few years, it seems like fewer and fewer people tune in to see the next wave of comedy superstars. The general consensus is that SNL has been having trouble getting with the times, especially when it comes to Gen-Z comedy. Now, as an avid SNL fan personally, there are still a few hits, most notably the ascendance of Marcello Hernandez and Jeremy Culhane’s recurring character, Mr. On Blast. However, it appears that in an effort to reach the youth, Lorne Michaels and company have added certain hosts across the spectrum of comedy, in front of the camera and in the writer’s room. Whether or not that is for the good of the show remains to be seen. Which brings me to one of them, Shane Gillis.

I first discovered Gillis, like I’m sure the majority of online users did, through clips of his comedy special on TikTok where he makes a pretty loving joke about his family members who have Down Syndrome. That sound has become pretty viral, as many use it to show their family members with Down Syndrome. I wanted to dig deeper, but the first thing you see (or saw before a couple of weeks ago) when you searched Gillis’ name was articles about his firing from SNL in 2019. Gillis was announced as an addition along with Bowen Yang and Chloe Fineman before some off-color clips of him using gay slurs on his podcast surfaced, and he was fired before making any appearances. So, unless you’ve been tapped into Gillis’ work, which is Joe Rogan/Theo Von adjacent, him popping up on SNL this October might appear random. But his hosting and the ensuing controversy speak to something much more intentional.

A couple of weeks ago, Gillis hosted Saturday Night Live for his third time. His last appearance gave us the CouplaBeers sketch, which had been a recent favorite in this new era of SNL, but this recent appearance was centered only around his monologue. Gillis used his opener to comment on women’s gym wear, saying that they “just dress like whores now”. The segment went over so badly that Gillis had to explicitly tell the live audience that his monologue was over and that they should be clapping. Tough scene. In the days following, many women took to the internet, posting pictures in their gym clothes, flipping Gillis’ words and taking their power back. In a vacuum, I’m sure this probably would’ve been the end of it, but in the wake of the recent Cornell 7 rape case, many audience members called on SNL cast members to comment on the controversy.

Saturday Night Live is no stranger to controversial moments, but, for my money, this might be the first time I’ve seen cast members disavow a host’s monologue. Michael Che, co-anchor on Weekend Update, was asked on The Today Show about Gillis, but he slyly avoided making any grand statements. Kenan Thompson, the longest-tenured cast member of SNL, was also asked about the segment, to which Thompson redirected the attention to the women cast members and the woman musical guest for that show, Rosalía, who were being overshadowed by the controversy. And that really encapsulates this whole thing. Because when this kind of humor is allowed a space on national television, the slope to treating women like objects, like things to see and use, becomes very, very slippery. If men don’t take it up amongst ourselves to stop misogyny, other men will take every opportunity to abuse their power.

I don’t really know what they were supposed to say, but in 2026, I would hope that comedians would be able to find ways to make people laugh without punching down. That’s like the first rule in the book. We saw this with Dave Chappelle’s obsession with trans jokes a few years back and the wave of right-leaning podcasts becoming more and more popular. These back-of-the-class jokes appeal to the lowest common denominator among us, and I just think Saturday Night Live is better than that. Especially considering that for the last decade, women have been carrying the show on their backs.

Tags : ComedySNL